Building discrepancy can help people find motivation to change …
Knowing that something in your life needs to change doesn’t necessarily mean you’re ready to do anything about it. Even when a behavior causes serious problems, the reasons for continuing it can seem more compelling than the reasons for stopping. The consequences may become so familiar that you gradually lose sight of how much they’re costing you.
One reason change can be so difficult is that people often have competing desires. Someone struggling with alcohol may want to stop drinking because of the problems it is causing, while also enjoying the temporary relief or pleasure that drinking provides. Both desires can be powerful, leaving the person caught between wanting things to improve and continuing the very behavior that is making life worse.
Yet there is another conflict that can be even more important. People have things they deeply value, such as their families, their health, their faith, or their hopes for the future. When their choices begin to interfere with those things, a troubling difference develops between the life they want and the life their behavior is producing. They may recognize individual problems without seeing how those problems are connected to what matters most to them.
Counselors have a name for this difference: discrepancy. The word simply means a gap or difference between two things. In this situation, it describes the gap between a person’s values and goals and the consequences of their current behavior. Recognizing that gap can provide a powerful reason to consider making changes.
Counselors sometimes help people explore this conflict through a process called building discrepancy. By asking questions that encourage people to examine their choices and their consequences, counselors help them recognize how continuing a behavior may affect the things they care about most. This approach is commonly used in motivational interviewing, a method of counseling that helps people work through conflicting feelings about change and discover their own reasons for pursuing it.
Counselors may use a handout to help clients build discrepancy. For example, someone struggling with alcohol or drug use can consider the following areas of life and compare the possible consequences of continuing to use with those of quitting.
| Area of life | If I continue using | If I quit using |
|---|---|---|
| My professional life or school | My performance may suffer, and I could lose opportunities or employment. | I could become more dependable, improve my performance, and pursue opportunities I’ve neglected. |
| My relationships with family and other loved ones | Broken promises and conflicts may further damage trust and closeness. | I could begin rebuilding trust and become more involved in the lives of people I love. |
| My relationships with friends | I may lose meaningful friendships or become increasingly involved with people whose lives revolve around substance use. | I could strengthen healthy friendships and develop relationships that support my recovery. |
| My long-term goals | My plans for the future may remain unfinished or become increasingly difficult to achieve. | I could devote more time and energy to pursuing the a better, healthier future for me. |
| My finances | I may continue spending money I need for bills, savings, and other responsibilities. | I could use that money to reduce debt, meet my obligations, and work toward financial security. |
| My health | I may experience worsening physical or mental health and greater risks associated with substance use. | I could reduce substance-related risks and give my overall health an opportunity to improve. |
| My relationship with God and my overall spiritual life | My substance use may continue interfering with prayer, worship, spiritual growth, and living according to God’s Word. | I could devote greater attention to my relationship with God and live more obediently to God. |
These are illustrative answers rather than the experiences of an actual client. The value of the exercise comes from the person’s own answers, which may reveal conflicts that are far more meaningful than the general consequences of substance use.
Someone might begin the exercise believing that drinking is primarily a financial problem, only to discover that the possibility of losing the trust of loved ones is much more troubling. Another person may recognize that substance use is interfering with a deeply valued relationship with God or a long-held ambition. When people identify what they stand to lose and what they hope to gain, their reasons for changing become more personal and concrete.
Building discrepancy can be used with other behaviors, including gambling, irresponsible spending, or habits that damage important relationships. Counselors encourage clients to examine these conflicts without shame or pressure, recognizing that people are more likely to embrace change when their motivation comes from their own rational thinking and priorities.
One question worth considering is how much of the future you’re hoping for depends on choices you’re making today. The answer may give an important decision a new sense of urgency.
Scotty

Leave a Reply